Today’s column addresses an issue that I haven’t previously written about on these pages…our southern border. As a Libertarian, I support, in the purest sense, the notion that restricting borders is antithetical to liberty. True freedom includes the right to move about without constraint as long as an individual respects the lives and property of others. Aha! There’s the rub. As a Libertarian, I believe that an individual owns his/her own life, labor and property…otherwise identified as free will. Libertarians also subscribe to the foundational precept that the initiation of force is an anathema. We do not oppose a fast, furious and final response when we are threatened or assaulted, but we adamantly oppose the use of force to impose one’s will (see IRS, ATF, DEA and a host of others).
To get our arms around the situation on our southern border (and northern, too), I’ll arbitrarily identify four groups of illegal border crossers. The first represents those Mexicans, Central Americans and South Americans who risk arrest to enter the United States for employment and opportunity. We’ll call them…the ants. The second cluster of people sneaks into our country to take advantage of the generous social welfare system. We’ll label them …the roaches. A third element of illegal immigration includes smugglers and their mules—drugs, guns, any contraband. These are multiple lawbreakers and are potentially dangerous. (We’ll deal with the drug issue in a later column). We’ll identify this group as the tarantulas. A final group includes those from all over the world who enter the United States with the sole intent to do harm to our citizens and their property. They are the scorpions.
Now we have the new border crossing taxonomy for illegal entrants into the United States. We have two insects and two arachnids, but because they all look like bugs, that’s close enough. You’ll note that the “ant” has historically been identified as a worker whereas the cockroach is a dirty disease carrier that avoids the daylight. The tarantula and the scorpion possess lethal capacity and are never to be trusted…or fondled. For the moment I’d like to concentrate on the overview of the issue.
First, because of the tarantulas and scorpions, it is vital that our borders be secured. No “ifs, ands or buts.” For decades the federal government has been derelict in its duty of providing a national defense. When borders as large as ours are so porous that nearly anyone can sneak into the country, the Congress, the Executive branch and the federal judiciary have committed impeachable offenses given the tenor of the times. Instead, the government has focused its efforts on the general population at large by severely restricting OUR freedoms through such devices as the Patriot Act and overzealous body groping by the TSA. Clearly the government is more willing to control our citizens than it is committed to limiting the access of nefarious killers who would do us harm. These priorities must be addressed and reversed. When any of these dangerous characters is apprehended, justice should be swift and firm.
My remedy for the issue of southern border leakage is to first SECURE THE BORDER. If we would close the bulk of our military bases in some 140 countries around the world and bring those troops back home, they could be deployed with the respective state guard organizations. The re-deployed regulars could be sent to theater (another column), and the guard could come home. With the guard as the primary lead force on the border, posse commitatus ceases to be the major legal concern. Also the wall/fence/barrier must be built. Plant land mines, if necessary.
Stop the benefits…immediately. Understandably if individual states and communities wish to continue providing benefits for “undocumented aliens,” they can do so…without any federal assistance whether direct, indirect or fungible. The responsibility must remain wholly within the entity that chooses to subsidize illegals. Also, the anchor baby program should be abolished along with the ability to invite extended family members. These measures should go a long way toward addressing the issues of the cockroaches.
Finally, wait a reasonable length of time…perhaps a year or so. At that point we should re-examine the situation. If we continue to have twelve to twenty million illegal aliens in country, then more stringent measures may be necessary. If, on the other hand, the illegal population becomes much smaller and the vast majority of those here are productive contributors, then a legitimate and restrictive pathway to citizenship could be devised. The ants would be given an opportunity to participate as citizens in our free-market country.
This is not a perfect solution. In fact if government were to adopt it, they most certainly would do it imperfectly. Government is incompetent and thoughtless. But if they were to implement this plan, we might be somewhat safer and the costs for our social services could be somewhat lower. Perhaps.
Face Book: www.facebook.com/pages/Earl-for-Ohio/
No comments:
Post a Comment